2010 Albums of the Year

|
Some have suggested that 2010 was a big year for music - But I cant agree. I thought the year lacked much in the way of depth and substance. I got excited a few times (Arcade Fire, Mogwai) found a few gems (Gonjasufi, The Morning Benders) but overall there was nothing entering my top 50 albums of all time list from 2010. Nothing game changing. Certainly nothing life changing. I guess we can hold some hope for 2011.


So without further ado............


The Top 10 albums of 2010.

..........and you will note that there is no Kanye West here. Not because you probably own it, but because I thought my beautiful dark twisted fantasy was absolute shite. Very well (if not slightly over-) produced, but for me it does not hold a candle to his first two albums. Dont buy it. Or even steal it. Not worth it.


10. 65daysofstatic - we were exploding anyway






















65dos continue to move into a more electronic post rock genre. At first i was not sold. Now - i like it. Its post rock math electronica, it has brilliant moments, others not so. Slightly challenging at first but i have grown to really like the intensity and complexity of the album.
7.5/10


9. The Black Keys - Brothers






















I guess you could say more of the same from the boys from Ohio. Its just awesome blues rock that harks back to their prime of 2002-2004 when they released The Big Come Up, Thickfreakness and Rubber Factory. After experimenting since then, including the rap-blues Blacroc, they have come the full circle, with a twist.  The experiments have led to better production, songs that are slightly toned down from the garage days. Its the Keys of old (with a drummer that knows how to play drums, unlike the white stripes) add some production and craftsmanship to the songs and you have brothers. Just ace blues rock.
7.5/10


8. Surfer Blood - Astrocoast.






















I heard the song Anchorage and was just blown away. It reminded me a perfect 1990s post grunge indie kind of anthem that just progressed perfectly. It was a perfect post grunge indie kind of anthem that just progressed perfectly - except it was 2010. The young lads from Surfer Blood produced a debut album that draws on those post grunge influences, you can tell these guys like early weezer (who doesn't) and they have drawn comparisons with Vampire Weekend, but ultimately they have created their own great guitar sound, with killer riffs and some fantastic anthemic songs - Swim, Floating Vibes and Anchorage are probably the picks.
7.5/10


7. Tame Impala - Innerspeaker.






















I have been waiting for the full length album from Tame Impala since the 2008 self titled EP with accompanying single 'Glass half full of wine captured my imagination. Well 2010 was the year - and this is a really good debut album. Unfortunately Psychedelic Rock is always going to draw comparisons to Cream, the Beatles, Hendrix, the Doors, Pink Floyd - and whatever is being held up to the legendary psychedelic bands is inevitably going to fail in comparison. But why compare? Enjoy it for what it is. The Western Australian lads do psychedelic rock very very well. This is a great trip through a fantastic genre and that is what i love about Tame Impala - they are making fantastic psych rock songs with a sound that could have been recorded anytime from 1970 to the present. As i said enjoy it for what it is the pre-eminent psychedelic rock band in the world right now.
7.5/10


6. The Morning Benders - Big Echo.























I found this through my 2009 album of the year Veckatimest - Grizzly Bear. (see my review here). Chris Taylor from Grizzly Bear co-produces, so the experimental rock sound that i liked so much last year is present here, but at the same time is quite different from GB. Seemingly full of Easy going and charming songs, the album needs to be listened to properly, below the surface lingers that experimental side. The weirdness and wonder emerges as the album progresses you can definitely hear the cavernous production that they were looking for. Thoroughly enjoyable.
7.5/10




5.  Gonjasufi: A Sufi And A Killer





















I have no idea where I first heard this, im still not sure I understand it, i know i don't need or pretend to. I just love it. This bearded dread locked mystical looking crooner who moves between spoken word, singing and rapping over the top of spaced, funky beats created by Gaslamp Killer with his eerie, gruff, haunting and instrument like voice. Its not Rap, Its not hip hop. Who knows what it is. Its just awesome. Great production with heavier songs, ballads, eastern influences and guitars that somehow all coming together to add to the mystique....... intrigued?

You should be. Get it.
8/10

4. Arcade Fire - The Suburbs.






















Underwhelming. For me. A very very good album, but in light of the pedestal that i have the Arcade Fire sitting atop (see their Funeral album entry here) i just thought they could have done better. But im sure they dont care what i think.. Had its high points (The Suburbs, Modern Man, The Sprawl II, Rococo) But a long album with a bit of filler and a few ordinary songs. But. like a said, good, very good- but i just expected this to be number the album of the year, if not the decade. Get it - it is fantastic, just not as fantastic as I wanted!
8 / 10

3. Mogwai - Special Moves.























Well it is Mogwai. How could i not love it and want you to own it? I do love Mogwai - a lot (see here). This is an absolutely fantastic live album, featuring almost everything a fan could want. 'Hunted by A freak', 'Mogwai Fear Satan', 'I'm Jim Morrison, Im Dead' 'Cody' and of course the incomparable 'Like Herod'. Just when you think they have peaked with Like Herod, outcomes the most balltearing rendition of 'Glasgow Mega-snake' you have ever heard.  When i first laid my hands on the album i held fears that the true sound of Mogwai would not be captured live, the layers, the distortion, the intricacies.  But my fears were quickly laid to rest - one of the best production efforts on a live album i have ever heard. If you are not a Mogwai fan (i pity you) and i have got some feedback, "great blog, not sure about Mogwai though" - this is not the best entry point, however a relaxing listen, alone, headphones on, dark, no distractions -  just be an aural delight.
I look forward to their upcoming release 'Hardcore will never die, but you will' - Top of my most anticipated list in 2011.
8/10



2. LCD Soundsystem - This is Happening.




















OK I concede that people might own this, or at least have downloaded "Drunk Girls" from itunes or similar. This is apparently James Murphys final album, and it might just be his best. Dance Punk Indie Electronic? I dont know, but it makes me, of all people, who is renowned as a non dancer - want to get up and dance. His musical influences have never been hidden, its all here, but a more mature sound than on the past 2 albums. Those last 2 albums had killer singles (can anyone not want to dance to 'daft punk is playing at my house'?) but as albums lacked the depth and complexity here. The combination of fantastic production, memorable basslines with some crazy guitar and 70s synth make this one a must own. Dance Yourself Clean, Drunk Girls, One Touch, All I Want, I Can Change & Home, are all just fantastic songs for a man who copied everything and spun it with dance beats to make his own genre.
8.5/10



1. Deerhunter - Halcyon Digest





















The most accessible album by Deerhunter to date and certainly the best. This is the perfect mixture of sonic psychedelia with interludes of indie pop and dreamy sequences that somehow move between over and underproduction. But dont let that put you off. Dripping guitar riffs and synthesizers awash with glorious emotive feeling permeate around longing vocals with maximum emotional impact as the band lays down increasing lush, crystallized music in the background as the album goes on. Perfect album and the best of 2010.

9/10


Mogwai - Young Team.

|
Young Team


Describing Mogwai to the uninitiated is not an easy task. The only thing that i can confidently say is that it's like nothing you've ever heard before. The Scottish lads 1997 debut 'Young Team' is one of the most genre-defying albums I have ever heard. It is very unique. Far too dynamic to be considered minimalism, too jarringly noisy and heady to be sad-core, yet the gentle soothing passages throughout are far too ambient to be considered noise-rock. Post Rock is the genre usually attached to Mogwai - but what the hell is post rock? This is just beautiful music.


"If the stars had a sound it would sound like this"
-Yes, I Am a long way from home




It is largely instrumental, with brooding, slow burning escalations of poignant, dark music with melodic washes of distortion that ebb and flow and build to almighty crescendos. There is a fine line between calm and chaos and this album walks that line with amazing poise.

This album encompasses, in a little over an hour i might add, pretty much everything that other bands in the genre of 'post rock' aspire to. It has menace and delicacy, abruptness and linearity, mystery and well-tempered artistic posturing. After listening to this you could argue that this album has had a more profound effect on hundreds of other artists than any other in the past 15 years or so.

It is refreshing in the sense that it's arty, dissonant, ambient, tasteful and well-produced. The sound is enormous. The music itself requires patience, because it does take a few listens to really sink in, but when it does you will be lost in the beauty of the sound. Lyrics are minimal, but dont get hung up on that.

I think most people are not used to having no lyrics to focus on. Lyrics are a real comfort to some people. I guess they like to sing along and when they can't do that with us they can get a bit upset. —Stuart Braithwaite

When i first heard this album, it hit me with such an impact that it forever changed how I listen to music and what I feel about it. It still blows me away today. Mogwai heralded something challenging and different to what I previously knew about music.

This album is the ultimate brooding, burning and possibly the most epic thing i think i have ever heard. This is heavy, but oh so pretty, dark and romantic, but also creepy and seriously ominous sounding. Soft, super blissed out meandering and almost ambient soundscapes with dark brooding passages of near silence, eventually shattered into a million pieces by bursts of frenzied, rhythmic noise, crushing and metallic and machine like, but always ready to drift and fade back into soft swooning tranquility and beauty. Even the loud and heavy parts are strangely melodic and ridiculously catchy.

'Yes, I am a long way from home' starts the album, a quotation followed by a lovely introduction, bass with a clean drum and a quiet melodic guitar riff over the top, the instruments fade in and out before the music works towards a crescendo of distortion while maintaining a soaring guitar rhythm before falling back into the outro. This leads into 'Like Herod', on first hearing this song i was completely spellbound by the rhythmic opening and i was seduced into an almost trance like state as a listened to the parts, fade in and out the layers of instruments and then.....BANG  it was like getting hit in the face with a brick. The thunderous explosion of every instrument in a barrage of deafening noise, featuring a heavy drumbeat and highly distorted, screeching guitars that somehow find themselves back in their original quite melodic state within a short space of time. WOW. This song is an extreme display of Mogwai's quiet/loud dynamic contrast method that they are well known for and it is over 11 minutes of intensity.

'Katrien' continues with a beautiful melodic guitar line coupled with a spoken word lyric and some ferocious drumming, that moves into the same distorted melody before coming up for air. 'Radar Maker' serves as a piano interlude before the outstanding 'Tracy'. Instead of being predominantly guitar-based and featuring heavy dynamic contrast like the rest of the album, this song is based around a glockenspiel, remaining dynamically quiet throughout but having an ominous feeling that at any second it could explode as it works its way to a peak, the guitar, bass and drums working together but the calm of the glockenspiel wins out. In the background are two sampled telephone calls regarding disagreements between band members. It is a gorgeous and intriguing song in the midst of chaos. Back to the melodic anarchy with 'Summer (priority version)' before 'With Portfolio' brings a piano interlude with samples that morphs into a distorted static flicking from left to right speaker. I'm sure there was a reason for this, it really is confronting.

The mellow 'R U Still into it' is the only song on the album that is not an instrumental, the lyrics telling the tale of a relationship that appears to be over, slow and sad it leads into the penultimate song 'A cheery wave from stranded youngsters' which continues along the same route, a slow melodic and rhythmic take down to prepare you for the finale, the 16 minute 'Mogwai Fear Satan'. This is the Pièce de résistance, a song that is gorgeous, sublime, somehow deliberately and intricately cathartic and freakishly mind blowing and brutal as it works your brain through each stage taking you on a journey that for me is completely engrossing and absorbing each time i listen to it. I cant do anything but listen in awe.

This music can put a human being in a trance like state and deprive it for the sneaking feeling of existing. Music is bigger than words and wider than pictures.
-Yes, I Am a long way from home


Mogwai focus on shifting momentum between subtle understated melody and completely contrasting against that with explosive guitar noise & feedback that needs the volume turned up several notches to fully appreciate the complex texturing. Tracks lull you into a sense of security with rhythmic melodies that once you have accepted subsequently burst into feedback awash with furious musical intertwining. It is a sonic epic as the band break new ground by being non-conformist & ambitious, it is important, refreshing, complex, different and like nothing you have every heard before. It is not for everyone, its not party music, it is personal and it is for the right mood - but give it a chance and you might find yourself lost in this fantastic album.

It is truly astonishing.

Elliott Smith - Either / Or

|

Elliot Smith - if you have never had the pleasure of an introduction - was one of the most talented singer songwriters of the 1990s/early 2000s. Back when Indie was still independent and underground, Smith used a his multi instrumental talents, a 4 track recorder and the bedrooms, bathrooms, basements and living rooms of various houses to create some of the most poignant songs you could ever wish to hear. Taking some strange form of inspiration from a childhood of broken marriage, abuse and a lifetime of battling drug and alcohol addiction, Smiths lyrics cover a range of topics that paint a picture of a man fighting with the world, sometimes coming up roses, but other times not.

Signed to the aptly named Kill Rock Stars label, he had released 3 albums before having a few tracks included on the soundtrack for the film Good Will Hunting. This would lead to an academy award nomination for best song and widespread acclaim and exposure. He signed a deal with multi-national giant Dreamworks. The 'stardom' that followed led to increased drug and alcohol use, suicide attempts and a downward spiral that ended in his premature death from two stab wounds to the chest that were possibly self inflicted, his death was never ruled a suicide.

Elliot Smith was the antithesis of grunge, a lo-fi / folk indie singer-songwriter, who despite his musical differences was very much like the poster boy for grunge music Kurt Cobain. Both were extremely talented, they shied away from the limelight and struggled with fame, battled addiction and ultimately died by their own hand - well before their time. Just amazing lyricists and musicians.  Sometimes i think there is a certain kind of fatalistic relationship that was pertinent to the success and ultimately the death of the likes of Kurt Cobain, Elliot Smith, Jim Morrison and Ian Curtis. The lyrical content of the songs is very personal and emotional at times, about abuse, drugs, depression and 'non mainstream' topics. The inability to deal with fame and fortune that follows hastens what was possibly inevitable from the outset. Would the cohort of songwriters who are tormented by their childhoods, suffer depression, have alcohol & drug abuse problems and use this as their inspiration be able to succeed as artists with out it? Anyway, I am thinking out loud - that's a question for someone else.

Elliott Smiths 1997 album 'Either/Or' takes its name from Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard's book of the same name. Smith stated in a few interviews that the album follows Kierkegaard's philosophy in relation to the absurdist struggle between choosing an aesthetic life and an ethical life. Quite clearly the battles that Smith had with himself are evident here. In the first paragraph of that book, Kierkegaard speaks of a poet as being a person whose lips are shaped in such a way that their sighs of sorrow sound to us, the audience, like beautiful music. Elliott Smith's music is some of saddest and also the most beautiful, that I have ever heard.

With a few simple chords, some delicate finger plucking, and a flicker of his thin voice, Elliott Smith created haunting, beautiful and intimate songs. It's quite an accomplishment that he was able to craft one of the best albums of the 1990's with virtually no more than his voice and an acoustic guitar. His songwriting would make this an enthralling album even if the lyrics were spoken in a slow monotone.

Either/Or opens with 'Speed Trials' - possibly about drugs but not blatantly obvious. Smith sets the template for what is to follow throughout the album; an absolutely beautiful voice accompanied by an acoustic guitar, with the occasional drum beat thrown in the mix. But it is the introspective lyrics that always make me think when i hear this. You can imagine him late at night, huddled over his small home recorder feeling guilty about his addiction.....
"You little child, what makes you think you're tough?
When all the people you think you're above
They all know what's the matter
You're such a pinball, yeah, you know it's true
There's always something you come back running to
To follow the path of no resistance
It's just a brief smile crossing your face
Running speed trials standing in place"
'Alameda' follows with a beautiful melody, simple drums (as does most of the album) and an almost ethereal lyrical delivery, but it belies the bittersweet content. The lyrics are directed towards someone, maybe even himself.
"Nobody broke your heart, You broke your own because you can't finish what you start. If you're alone it must be you that wants to be apart"
'Ballad of Big' nothing continues along a similar path, incisive lyrics that lead to the haunting 'Between the Bars' which consists of nothing but Elliott and a guitar and his alcoholism. This was one of the songs off of Either/Or that would be selected for "Good Will Hunting" and is one of the most moving and endearing songs Smith ever recorded. 'Pictures of me' changes pace slightly, more up beat dealing with the fame, the media and the fact he is not what he appears.

No Name No.5 (he had 6 songs on his albums called No Name #...., four appear on the Roman Candle Album) has a fantastic guitar riff, just a simple but great chord progression that builds through the song. His quiet voice is able to create a wonderful melody for a song that i truly love. The observational 'Rose Parade' and melancholy Punch and Judy "I think I'm going to make the same mistake twice" lead to "Angeles", a fantastic song with brilliant guitar about the bright lights and offers from LA, the money and the promises.
"I could make you satisfied in everything you do
All your secret wishes could right now be coming true
And be forever with my poison arms around you"
The most rocking track on the album 'Cupids Trick' is the only one featuring electric guitar, it's louder and faster than the rest of the album. Elliott Smith was quoted in Spin Magazine saying, "I've written a lot of stuff being on something. Drinking or doing drugs doesn't make it any easier, but it's different, you know?... that song, 'Cupids Trick' on Either/Or- the rock song? I made that up while in a state, and I have no idea what I was talking about. It made perfect sense to me at the time, but now it's just a bunch of words."

My favourite Smith song is '2:45 am'. It leaves me speechless and numb, yet impassioned. Quite amazing for a song that is just a quiet acoustic guitar and voice until three quarters of the way through when the drums and a fuzzy bass kick in. Again the lyrics leave a lot to be thought about when you consider his background.

Somehow 'Say Yes' manages to finish the album on a rather uncharacteristically positive note, but continues the stripped down feel. Just vocals and an acoustic guitar again - but of course the 'love' song has that special edge to it that only Elliott Smiths lyrics can add.

It is impossible to speak of this album in anything less than superlatives. It is one of those few albums that necessitates the first listening be without interruption, from the first to the final track. Elliott's overlayed voice barely rises above a whisper, and many of the songs include only acoustic guitars and bare percussion. But the solitude and concentration of the arrangements, performed by Smith alone, allows more musical depth, in the subtlety of his intonation or the phrasing of his guitar, than a collaborative or more orchestrated effort could possibly achieve. His lyrics are understood only in the context of the music, and walk that fine line between abstraction and articulation so that the listener understands perfectly his message, though perhaps that message is different for every listener.

The simplicity of this album is the very thing that makes me think it is his finest. The 'commercial' label follow ups 'X/O' and 'Figure 8' certainly have their moments, they are more heavily instrumented, more produced and lack nothing lyrically, however for me they do not have the profound affect that the intimacy of 'Either/Or' has on the listener. Each and every one of his albums is a must own in my book, but 'Either/Or' sits on a lofty pedestal because of the astonishing affect it has.

There is no musician to compare to Elliott Smith, not because he is perfectly original, but because he created a perfect balance of poetry and subtle music that complement each other so absolutely - any attempt at comparison would lack dimension. It is pointless.

Essentially, if you have sat in a room and listened to music and just been absorbed by it, if you have that patience and capacity to hear and be moved, then this is an album that you should own. If you like harmonies this is a must own. If you like simple arrangements, this is a must own. If you like songwriting, If you like honest emotions and great lyrics, you need to get this album.

It's the kind of album that people will be listening to twenty years from now. - i know i will.


Tool - Ænima

|
"Our goal remains to touch our audience on a deep, psychological level"

Clearly one would be hard pressed to name a major band that has ever been more cloaked in mystery and intrigue than Tool. From their earliest days in 1992, following the release of their debut EP 'Opiate' the band began perfecting their unique formula for success. By the time of their first Album 'Undertow' the plan for world domination was well in motion; create some of the most thought-provoking, experimental and downright amazing music in the world, release it on an unsuspecting public with a certain level of disturbing imagery, accompany it with mind blowing live shows and with the terrifying, captivating and award winning videos for 'Prison Sex' and 'Sober' you have probably grabbed everyones attention. Along the way avoid most interviews, promos & photos and with the small amount of information that is available, make it just obscure enough to maintain the curisoity of the masses. The whole point of these anti-marketing efforts is to what end?

Well, to the guys in Tool - It's about the music.

People enjoy music on many levels. Some people enjoy it sonically – they just dig the riffs, beats and melodies in the music because they make them feel something, for whatever reason. Some people really get lost in the lyrics and what they mean, whether that be what the band intended them to mean, or their own interpretation. Others admire technical perfection, the mastery of sections that are really difficult to play. Tool create music that works on so many levels, for so many people, for so many reasons. Don't be drawn into comparisons or genres here, i know plenty of people who love Tool but dislike heavy music.

"Our music has to inspire us and make us think- and it has to inspire everyone who hears it. It must make them think too, If it doesn't do that, then what was the point of making it in the first place?"

So with a phenomenal debut ('Undertow') behind them, Tool released the difficult second album.
Far from the rushed, overproduced and poorly written tripe that artists so often cough up on their second release, Tool made what is quite possibly the finest album of the nineites - in 1996 along came Ænima.

For me this is one of 'those' albums - one that changes your life.

I was brought up on a steady diet of the Beatles, The Rolling Stones, a bit of Elvis, Creedence Clearwater Revival, Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin. (Isn't hindsight is a majestic thing - thanks Dad) Then my tastes matured, young ears discoverd new sounds, not liking much of it (to this day i still can not listen to commercial radio) and then of course I, like everyone else at the time, became totally absorbed in the in Nirvana, Pearl Jam & Soundgarden. Despite this shaping my formative years of music with an alternative and somewhat anti authoritarian outlook of the world, i have considered myself always very open minded when it comes to music. By this stage I had been through a metal phase (and just so we are clear it was proper old school metal - Metallica, Slayer, Megadeth, Anthrax and Sepultura, not Poison and Skid Row) and was pretty happy where music was at, alternative, but then along came Ænima.

Tool pursued their vision as artists to create a brilliant and original album. This is one of the most complex albums i have ever heard, both lyrically and musically. To properly sit and listen to this album in its entirety can be almost overwhelming. Musically it can be confronting, with layers of expertly crafted riffs and sounds driving and intensifying to build towards a climax and provide an amazing base for lyrics that are confronting, through provoking and deep - very deep. It is an absolute experience, an emotional and sometimes fearsome journey that is a cerebral joy. If you do not like deep, dark, cathartic and artsy music you might not get what Aenima is about, but why underestimate yourself?


Ænima is constantly elapsing into new and ethereal territory, as each track rolls right off the other. Each track sets the mood for the next and the album just flows. It works on so many levels it's simply insane. It could stand alone as one of the best rock albums ever, it's possibly one of the most innovative pieces of music out there and could well be the smartest musically and lyrically you'll ever hear.

For me the lyrical focus is on philosophy and spirituality, it deals constantly with themes of change, rebirth, destruction and reconstruction, realisation and new beginnings. The title of the album finds its roots in the psychology of Carl Jung and this album is heavily influenced (in my opinion) by his writings. This is a dark, disturbing journey through the ugly underbelly of the human mind. No singer captures the ambivalence and terror of the human experience as well as Maynard James Keenan. When he and his bandmates are at full speed, they're untouchable. It is hard to beleive that the sounds on this album come from one guitar, one bass, one drum kit and when you add Maynards voice, which is an instrument in its own right, you have a combination that is breathtaking.

The album opens with the anthemic Stinkfist. Seeming to be a relatively simple song about addiction, Stinkfist uses the rather disgusting metaphor of fisting (think body cavity search fetish and you’re on the right track) to convey both the extent of addiction and the incremental increase in desperation in the addict — to find or feel something alive and hopeful in themselves. The search can, of course, ultimately lead only to recovery or destruction. Widely banned or strongly censored by commercial radio in conservative countries, it has been suggested that the offensive metaphor acts as a challenging entrance to the album; those not willing to look and think beyond superficial meanings should turn back now.
Another interpretation, this one raised by Maynard in an interview, relates to digging and pushing through one’s own self, particularly through layers of ugliness, to reach something valuable and enlightening.
The thunderous bass and intricate drumming build through the song with a great guitar riff, all beautifully supported by maynard moving his voice between a whisper (in portugese) a sweet melody and a vicious roar. An exceptional song to open an exceptional album.

To me at least, Eulogy is a relatively straightforward (for Tool) and aggressive work against the betrayal and misleadership of martyrs. Im content with holding the target of the song as representative of any or all false martyrs, however there has long been intrigue into just who the martyr might be. There is very solid case to make that the song is written for the late political comedian, Bill Hicks. Strongly and vocally opinionated, intelligent, articulate, pro-drug, vehemently opposed to U.S. hegemony and the armed forces, Hicks was a close friend of the band, and it is believed that his influence on Maynard was significant. Other ideas floated include Henry Rollins, Jesus himself (although i doubt this) Kurt Cobain etc etc.

Its an angry song and it definetley directed at someone, when sings
"Come down.......Get off your fuckin cross......We need the fuckin space.......... to nail the next fool martyr"
you can just hear the venom in his voice. The guitar in this song is amazing and the huge bass and drums again provide a rich texture. Amazing.

'H' is an extremely powerful and emotional song seemingly about the birth of Maynards son. He once said in an interview when asked about who or what is H - "My son’s name is Devo H. That’s all I’ll say." It couild be about Heroin addiction but i doubt that somehow. It seems to be in reference to his sons birth and of seeing elements of himself in him. He has concerns about the cyclic nature of abuse and doubts about his ability as a father and a concern that his past will compromise his ability to be a good father father, while on the other hand, the love for his son calls him to open up vulnerabilies and compassions that abuse may have hardened in him. Too connected to his son to escape his fears by simply leaving; as this new relationship forms and grows, the father is changing and his hardened self is weakening. He finally opens up and lets his defences down.

His love for his son is enough to defeat his inner demons and he comes to realize that there were many times like this when he should have opened up and been more emotionally honest. Demons defeated and looking forward now, he is free and able to love with commitment again. The future is full of possibility.

I think this song is really pivotal on the album, if you like it represents the end of the 'opening stanza' that is filled with agression and anger but its like something changes here. Change finally brought about by the birth of his son. The music here completments this change so well. Starting off with a beautiful timed drum beat with a soft hi-hat you again see the technical brilliance of a man widely acclaimed as the best drummer in the business. The intro is in a fantastic sounding minor key, the rise and fall of the guitar with the mood, the changing nature of Maynards voice is on show as always - His ability to hold a note for an astonishing period of time is on show here and if you have ever seen it live, it is a definite concert highlight.

The next short track is Useful idiot - the sound of a vinyl record at the end of its play, with the needle bumping up against the end of its track. More evidence that it is changing time.

Forty-Six & 2 makes many people’s list as one of the greatest rock epics of all time and really is one of the pivotal tracks on the album, being extremely focused and summary of the themes of change and rebirth that make up Ænima. While it is perhaps one of the most concise and punchy tracks on the album, it is also one of the most densely layered, making reference to several schools of thought on life, consciousness, humanity, change and personal evolution. It s a deep song again containing a number of Jungian references, particularly the 'shadow'. For me its the start of change, clearly highlighted by
"I’ve been crawling on my belly, Clearing out what could’ve been, I’ve been wallowing in my own confused and insecure delusions, For a piece to cross me over or a word to guide me in, I wanna feel the changes coming down, I wanna know what I’ve been hiding in".
Again though the music is just phenomenal. Such a brilliant guitar riff, the unbeleiveable percussion and bass combination and the prescence of the voice. Mindblowing.

Message to Harry Manback serves to break things up, its an actual answering machine recording from a friend of Maynards, i guess they thought it was amusing.

Hooker with a Penis is Tool’s blatent comment on consumerism and the somewhat contrieved notion of bands ‘selling out’ — something that suspiciously coincides with a band breaching a certain threshold of popularity or commercial success...... but the song talks about the sacrifices made and the tangled mess of corporate power. Its a great song that might not have the depth of the others but serves its purpose here.

Intermission is a short electronic organ mutation of the next song, Jimmy, but its light hearted carnival and childish nature belies what is about to come......

Jimmy is another extremely personal song by Maynard, seemingly about his childhood. Continuing with the change theory, He has realiseds that his problems are rooted in a trauma that he suffered when he was eleven. Taken autobiographically, the singer is likely referring to an accident that his mother suffered when he was eleven that left her paralysed and unable to care for him. Clearly, his mother’s paralysis caused the singer some significant trauma, and by recognising this, he is able to work through the conflicted and painful emotions that he felt in order to finally overcome it. A slow song that builds towards a realisation both lyrically and musically. The power builds as the lyrics relect an understanding of what needs to be done and finshes with "i'm heading back home".

The indsutrial Die Eier von Satan (or the eggs of satan for those not versed in German) might seem bizzare at first, but it serves a purpose here. The moral to this one is that things are not always as they seem. Tool’s most consistant message to their listeners is that they should think for themselves, and “question everything”. It shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise then that what sounds like a Nazi propaganda rally is actually a recipe for hash cookies. There is also a parallel between the reactions of people to perceived evils – those who would be up in arms about “that Nazi song” might just be the very same who would be outraged that a band would condone drugs and give you a good recipe for cookies. Think for yourself.......

and now we move into the last stanza, the final three songs that are just mindblowing.

Pushit is one of the reasons I love music. It describes the singer’s experiences as he confronts the most painful part of his journey - separating himself from an abusive relationship. Speculation again, an adult partner, abuse as a child, many theories abound, however what is clear is that the intensity and emotion evident in Pushit suggests that this is the most painful part of the whole 'process' that the album is detailing. To listen to this can be an experience in itself. To see it live (Tool have played this three of the four times i have seen the band) is confirmation about the emotion in this song. It is powerfully real and terryifying, yet this serves to create one of the most staggering songs i have ever heard and, as previously mentioned, seen live a number of times. The lyrics are clearly painful to Maynard and the platform that he gets to perform on, a grinding, building riff on a wonderfull guitar effect, backed by some unbeleiveable drumming with masterful cymbal work and brilliant timing changes that blow me away every single time i hear it. It all leads to a mamoth lyrical and musical finale that stays with you long after it has finished.

Cesaro summability is another short intelude, basically a crying baby. Cesaro summability is a mathematical method that determines the summability of a sequence when it is not summable by standard means – basically any infinite sequence either diverges on a constant or goes to infinity. Tool use a lot of mathematics in their music, especially their timing and Danny Careys drums (the laterulus album makes heavy use of Fibonacci sequences) Birth, babies, same themes again but the song serves a lead into.....

The title track (although spelt differently), Ænema makes extensive use of hemiola, a musical technique in which the emphasis on timing changes (especially by the drummer) through repeated parts create an awesome effect.. For example, during the first verse, the beat appears to be in 4/4 timing, while toward the middle of the song when the lyrics from the first verse are repeated, the beat is in 3/4 timing. You can hear it and it is just noticeable but somehow alluring. The ever present guitar and drums just dominate here, a big guitar riff and a great beat help maynard tell the tale of seperating himself from society. Again the band reference the late great Bill Hicks’ stand-up comedy, Arizona Bay. In it, Hicks suggests that Los Angeles is beyond the moral point of no return, and ought to be destroyed for the good of the world. Buliding on that theme the lyrics talk of purification not only of LA but of himself. This is the pinnacle of his quest to purge himself of imperfections, to destroy the negative within himself and achieve personal renewal and purification. (more Jung!) and the message - "Try and read between the lines"

(-) Ions serves as a bridge into the finale. The electric buzzing sound is caused by a device called a Jakob’s Ladder – essentially two long metal rods which arc electricitybetween each other. The other sounds are an improvisation of the build up before a storm. The title refers to negative ions, which are famed for causing a feeling of freshness and wellbeing in humans when present in the atmosphere. Negative ions are found in the air in greatest numbers immediately before storms and near waterfalls

The last song on the album is the 13-minute long epic, Third Eye. It opens with a some Bill Hicks standup that is both part homage and part linking in with the themes. The idea of the “third eye” typically represents enlightenment, knowledge of inner realms, and spaces of higher consciousness; from a Jungian perspective, it refers to the state of full individuation, where one has completely assimilated all parts of their psyche into the Self. Thus, this song represents the culmination of the singer’s journey towards enlightenment and full self-knowledge. Lyrically Third Eye is so metaphorical and vague that one could interpret them in almost any way; furthermore, as the song is the culmination of all of the album’s themes, it is difficult to separate the concepts present. But.... It is an amazing song, it’s one of those that has to be played loud, especially to enjoy the build up and subtlety of the percussion in the early stages and held in the foreground of your attention. The constant building and breaking down of the music, the changes in vocal styles and the metaphorical but somehow poignant lyrics make for a stunning finale. When I listen to the album from start to finish and find Third Eye building to the screaming crescendo i really feel i have been on a journey, uplifted and enlightened and often quite effected by it all. This song just brings it all together so perfectly.

phew.

Without this record, your collection can't be considered complete.

If you dont own this - get it.

AND NOT JUST AN MP3 - do it justice - pay for a .flac or .ogg file at a minimum!
Then get some huge big expensive speakers or at least some decent earphones for yor iPod, some Grados or AKGs or the like.

I dare you - because i know you wont stop listenening for a week.

Arcade Fire - Funeral

|

Now here is an album that you positively must own.

I don’t care what genre or type of music you like, be it Death Metal, Soul or Classical. This is one album that transcends music. It is a beautiful piece of artwork and music at its best.


The Arcade Fire released their debut album 'Funeral' in 2004. It was given its title because several band members had recently lost members of their families: Régine Chassagne's grandmother died in June 2003, Win and William Butler's grandfather in March 2004, and Richard Reed Parry's aunt in April 2004. This is certainly not the focus of the album, but along the way it does deal with with death, sorrow and loss but also with new life, love and celebration. It is a highly emotive piece of work, both musically and lyrically.


Throughout Funeral, the band augments its five-piece line up with string sections, weaving near-cinematic, folk-influenced indie pop that is continually working towards a crescendo, songs bursting into life with emotional honesty and sheer joyousness. These songs have a way of manipulating your feelings - listening to this album is a journey.

The song writing is varied, there are vast, goosebump inducing anthems ('Neighbourhood #1', 'Wake Up') catchy indie pop ('Neighbourhood #2', 'Haiti') and straight ahead indie rock ('Neighbourhood #3', 'Rebellion (Lies)'). Throughout it all, there's an astonishing variety of instrumentation. Sure there's your basic guitar/bass/drums line-up, but it's tempered with pianos, keyboards, xylophones, cellos, violins and even an accordion.

Funeral kicks off with four of the first 5 songs titled Neighbourhood.  Starting with 'Neighbourhood #1 (Tunnels)' - snow buries the houses and our narrator and his lover tunnel out and make their way to the middle of the town. This goes on over a gorgeous piano and xylophone twinkling, but the drums are building and the song just gets better and better. The second neighbourhood tune, 'Neighbourhood #2 (Laika)' is emotionally driven and resonating beyond this realm, with talk of vampires, the accordion appears here (French sounding?) leading into the mellow, half French piece "Une Annee Sans Lumiere," - darkness enveloping the neighbourhood for a year and hiding things (at least this what i am led to believe from my French translations.......) This is one of the most amazing songs on the album. The French mixed with English lyrics are laid back as Win Butler duets with his wife and co-songwriter Régine Chassagne, and the finale explodes with guitar driven energy.

We then move to 'Neighbourhood #3 (Power Out)' which seems to confirm my French to English translations about darkness and hidden meaning, but with a much heavier edge to it. The neighbourhood tale is concluded with 'Neighbourhood #4 (Kettles)' - a pensive realisation about the circle of life - talk of the elderly and babies - "Time keeps creepin' through the neighbourhood, killing old folks, wakin' up babies just like we knew it would".

These thoroughly well written, highly emotive, deep and meaningful lyrics are over a stunning backdrop of ever changing musical styles that that enhances the whole experience. Nearly all of the tracks are forever building into something incredible, with finales that will keep you replaying the song over and over again.

Then we move to the second half of Funeral.

'Crown of Love' is dark ballad about love, held firmly together by a power driven string section. Butler constructs a complex piece here - brilliant music, brilliant lyrics. It builds up over and over to a huge ending with a a great dance beat. 'Wake Up' is a extraordinary song, heavy guitars with an underlying orchestral arrangement makes it beautiful and very moving and yet absolutely rocking at the same time. I loves it.

‘Haiti’ is a love ballad to the homeland of Regine Chassagne that "she'll never see". She sings of "unmarked graves where flowers grow" and promising that "all the tears and all the bodies will bring about our second birth.", a real reminder about the terrible past of Haiti that is extremely poignant now with the recent events there.

'Rebellion (Lies)' is one very cool song. Very catchy, nice use of just two piano notes. I'm not even sure how they do it sometimes. Listen to the piano.... Two notes.... Drums.... Three beats.... Simple chords.... And yet, it's so dynamic, deep, and emotional. This song just further highlights the artistry of Arcade Fire.

The album closes with ‘In the Backseat’, Female vocals again with an almost ethereal Chassagne pondering the outside world from the backseat of a car. The music builds and becomes heavier as the song progresses, relying on heavy drums and powerful guitar chords. Building is a theme on the album, all the songs build up to something - this song though is just another masterpiece; a triumphant piece of music. It's the perfect closer for the perfect album.

When it ends, if feels like you've just finished some incredible experience - and you will want to start over! I have lost count of the number of times i have played this back to back. A true sign of a great album is that it gets better with every listen, you love it start with and it keeps getting better. Musically and lyrically it is sublime.

Overall, the Arcade Fire manage to collect a life's worth of images and emotions and fit them into a ten track album. From Bitterness and hope to love and solitude, this dark toned album is uplifting as it progresses through its countless stages.

This is an indie-rock epic that in my opinion is the best album made 2000-2009.

Enough said?

Miles Davis - Kind of Blue

|
A great many things in life are over-hyped, especially things that were huge and revolutionary for their times. There is an expectation that these pieces of 'art' are masterpieces and a widely held belief that there is something wrong with you if you don’t like it - be it music, film or literature. We have all been let down before by the classic film that was just boring, the classic book that you didn't finish or the classic album that you found pretentious or an affront to your ears. Did your friends call you unsophisticated? Uneducated? Did they tell you that you just did not get it?

That's alright – Kind of Blue is one of the few celebrated works of art that lives up to the hype and then goes far beyond it.


There's not a thing I could tell you about this masterpiece that hasn't been written before. This album is absolutely essential for anyone even remotely interested in music of any kind. You have certainly heard this album before at some point in your life whether you were aware or not. That is unless you suffer agoraphobia and don’t listen to music or watch television. Chances are you are probably not reading this right now


The background:


Miles Davis is renowned as one of the most important and innovative musicians of the 20th Century. As a bandleader, he led nearly every important jazz musician of the post-war period at some time, including: John Coltrane, Paul Chambers, Cannonball Adderley, Bill Evans, Herbie Hancock, Wayne Shorter, Tony Williams, Dave Holland, Chick Corea and Keith Jarrett.
Miles is credited as being the instigator of a number of styles in jazz. Cool Jazz, Modal Jazz and Jazz-Fusion are all his doing. He had already released over 20 albums and been a band leader for over 10 years when Kind of Blue was released in 1959. Miles has planned for Kind of Blue to be a masterpiece before the first note was played.

He picked the perfect cast to execute what was a fundamentally liberating idea. Until this point the dominant style of jazz was bebop and within this the improvisation was based on chords and chord changes. On this album Davis chose a completely different direction for the music - he called it 'Modal Jazz'. The entire album was composed as a series of modal sketches, in which each performer was given a set of scales that defined the parameters of their improvisation and style rather than the musicians being given a set of chord progressions. This provided a platform for improvising on each chord compared to conventional jazz tunes and standards.

Sounds like boring rhetoric?

If you are not up with the nuances and technicalities of music (especially Jazz music) I will make it more simple

This changed everything...........

The band itself is extraordinary. Two of the most celebrated men to ever pick up a saxophone appear - John Coltrane and Julian "Cannonball" Adderley - both who went on to become renowned in their own right. For the large part Bill Evans is on piano (with Wynton Kelly playing on one track) and Paul Chambers on bass and Jimmy Cobb on drums make what is the tightest ever rhythm unit that I think I have ever heard on any kind of music.

To put this in perspective, Miles Davis assembled a quintet that contained musicians who are widely regarded as some of the finest to ever pick up their respective instruments. (Although I am not sure Gil Evans ever picked up his piano – they are heavy). Almost a supergroup!
Coltrane's sharpness on tenor is countered by Adderley's funky alto, with Davis on trumpet moderating everything and changing with the mood. Bill Evans conjures up a brilliant sound on piano, a platform for the solos of Miles, Coltrane and Adderley. Meanwhile, the rhythm partnership of Cobb and Chambers underpin the whole thing with timing that is just impeccable - for me it almost proves the existence of God. I could write another whole piece just on the bass playing of Chambers and the Jimmy Cobb drum fills.
Every musician gets his time to shine, everyone has solos and ever note is to perfection - even with improvisation.

Miles and his band created an album with outstanding mood & melody, where all the notes ebb & flow and where all the musicians get to strut their stuff without stepping on each other. There's no instrumental ‘noodling’ to be found anywhere on Kind of Blue. If that is your impression of Jazz - you need to try again. The album has a great cohesiveness to it, where every improvised note you hear makes perfect sense. Miles Davis knew that musical magic could be achieved through spontaneity, as long as each piece had a basic "setting" for the musicians to work within.

From the classic opener "So What," to the concluding "Flamenco Sketches," the music is wonderful, melodic and breezy, but most of all, cool. It's amazing to think that this classic album was finished in a mere two sessions, with every track except one nailed down in a single take ("Flamenco Sketches" took two takes to complete).

"So What" is just the quintessential Jazz track, it is exciting and brilliant, "Freddie Freeloader" takes on a faster bluesy beat driven by Wyn Kelly on piano (It is Evans on the rest of the tracks). "All Blues" is my favourite above all other jazz songs, i close my eyes and i can almost hear all 11 minutes, that particular track has seeped into my consciousness and frequently plays itself in my head as i go to sleep.

It is a work of pure genius by a bunch of improvising musicians at the height of their powers. This is probably the album that has turned more people onto jazz than any other. It is said that this is the cornerstone of any Jazz collection, it is the highest selling Jazz album of all time, it is the most important and influential Jazz album of all time. But i think it should be viewed as the cornerstone of any record collection.

Even those who don't appreciate jazz should appreciate this album for its musicality and virtuoso performances. Yet it is so easily accessible. But if you only have one jazz album then this is the one to get, though I would suggest that this recording will be used as a launching pad into the world of jazz.
Kind of Blue is pure and majestic throughout - it is the most beautiful Album I have ever heard.

There are other fantastic Jazz Albums that you probably don’t own but really should, Giant Steps and A Love Supreme by John Coltrane, Cannonball Adderley's Somethin’ Else, Time Out by Dave Brubrek - I could go on and on, but I am not trying to sell this as a Jazz album - im selling this as possibly the best album I own.

The only valid reason I can think of to not own this, is that you own the Miles Davis/ John Coltrane Complete Columbia Recordings 6 CD Box Set which includes this album in its entirety.

If you have it - great, i am certain you will concur.
If you don’t own it - get it.
If you don’t like Jazz - get it.
Get it.

You will never Ever regret it. It may change the way you to music listen forever - as it has with me.

2009 Albums of the year......

|
1. Veckatimest - Grizzly Bear.


More often than not music is referenced by other bands "it sounds like......" or "..... so is the new ......" Somehow Grizzly Bear has managed to sidestep these labels and create it's own music without falling into the pit of preconceived notions that genres create. In attempting to classify the album i though that a whole lot of adjectives would do the job, with none of it giving you any idea what was actually going on.

Call it Lo-Fi indie if you want a broad classification, but it is so much more than that. This is one amazingly crafted album and it is important to note - a whole album experience. Don't just download one song from iTunes - it will be good, but it will not do the whole thing justice. The album flows through movements taking you on a journey through moods and sounds. Every second of each song is in exactly the right place. The production values are sublime. The Album is dense and textured and yet somehow sounds so sparse and simple in other places. Veckatimest is complex and yet easily accessible. The ambition of the album is grand and the band have obviously pursed perfection - and in my eyes it is almost attained.

In a word it is quite simply stunning. What's so amazing about this album is that the attempts by most artists at achieving their lofty ambitions of perfection are inevitably ruined by a misplaced sense of what actually sounds good. This is usually caused by a combination of overproduction (name any number of moderately successful artists here who have delusions of grandeur, lets begin with The Killers), pretentiousness (Coldplay & Axl Rose spring to mind there) and of course the need for instant gratification (The Kings of Leon in the forefront of my mind there....) As Alex Turner of The Arctic Monkeys once sang "There's only music so that there's new ring tones". Anyway back to Grizzly Bear - there is no overproduction and no pretensions. Veckatimest is just so damn good. You keep coming back for more and more and strangely enough it keeps getting better and better. It sounds so familiar and yet you keep hearing more and more within the songs.

While you wait for the others is certainly one of my favourite songs of the year, but the album is full of brilliant tunes. Two Weeks, Dory & Cheerleader are highlights, while the pair of songs that close I live with you and Foreground finish the album on a splendid note.

If you have not heard it -get it. If you have it - make sure you see the magnificent film clips for Two weeks and while you wait...

This is one hell of an album, my best for 2009.



2. Fits - White Denim




Astonishing.

Fits is an extraordinary album, not just because it is so good, but because of the way in which this three piece from Texas write songs. Strap yourself in and hold on tight for 37 minutes of some of the most versatile and creative music you have every heard. White Denim are basically a Garage Rock band. Well maybe a caravan rock band, they recorded this album in drummer Josh Blocks caravan, either way that is just a starting point. Like Grizzly Bear, White Denim are hard to categorise (so why try) but basically the joy is in the sonic intensity that encapsulates your head and leaves you wanting more!


So we have Guitar, Bass & Drums as a starting point with wah wah pedals, psychedelia, ethereal harmonies, punk, jazz, prog rock, dub, soul, organs, sing along and some stoner rock thrown in, sometimes all in the course of one song.

Confused?

You should be.

It is like nothing you have ever heard before, but I have to say there is not an album out there that i have had more fun listening to than this - well flight of the conchords was fairly funny, but fun derived from music...... The chemistry between the members makes what really should not work a very cohesive album. Songs change halfway though and become something completely different, they speed up slow down, timing changes abound (Josh Block is an exceptional drummer). These guys are certainly very handy musicians and multi instrumentalists. Pianos, Organs, Saxophones and christ knows what else make appearances.

The songs are just so enjoyable. I start to run gets in my head and makes me want to dance (or run). Sex prayer is the most awesome organ driven dub rock turning to trippy psychedelia song i have ever heard. Although it could well be the first. El Hard Attack DCWYW is latin punk, Regina Holding Hands is beautifully acoustic, Radio Milk, How Can You Stand It thrashes around masquerading as a punk song before coming up bluesy. Syncn closes the album and makes you want to start it all over again.

There is a psychedelic weave throughout the album and this, combined with the rambunctious energy, has the whole thing teetering on the verge of combustion. However the absolutely stunning songs on Fits always manage to hold together and work themselves out with exciting, engaging results.

This is what bedlam sounds like.

And i like it.



3. Them Crooked Vultures - Them Crooked Vultures



Supergroups scare me.

They should scare you as well. The general equation would be to take good musicians and songwriters out of great groups and put them together and the sum of all the parts = musical gold. However this is almost never the case. The equation actually spits out something far worse than any of the individuals would ever imagined, instead of getting Voltron, you get the mighty morphin power rangers. Think Audioslave, Velvet Revolver, Zwan, The Highway Men, TheTravelling Wilburys (in their defence Roy Orbision did die........) all just bad - especially when compared to from where they came - Rage Against the Machine, Soundgarden, Guns N Roses, Stone Temple Pilots, The Smashing Pumpkins, Slint and individuals such as Bob Dylan, Roy Orbison, Tom Petty and George Harrison. Anyway, you get the message, all supergroups are bad and the only exception that i can make with any conviction is for Crosby, Stills & Nash (and Young).

But...........

Dave Grohl, the man who found himself in two of the biggest bands in the world of the last 20 years Nirvana and the Foo Fighters has made a habit of side projects. Grohl has worked with Queens of the Stone Age, Tenacious D and Probot among others - he likes it, says it is fun. His good mate Josh Homme has done the same - The Eagles of Death Metal & Desert Sessions. So to be clear, when you are still in a band (Foo Fighters or QOTSA) working on a side project, you are not in a supergroup. Therefore, it is OK to team up with your mate (Grohl and Homme) and find some old fellow who you happen to worship because he was in some band called Led Zeppelin (John Paul Jones) and form a band.

Now that i have proven that Them Crooked Vultures are a side project and not a Supergoup I can stop being scared and get on with loving the album.

What would you expect from Grohl (rock) Homme (mega rock) and JPJ (more rock than rock itself). Ah - heavy guitars and drums and rock. yep. rock.

Guess what. This album rocks.

Firstly, thank God that Dave Grohl has got back behind a drumkit. This is where he belongs. He really is one hell of a drummer and with JPJ on bass showing he has lost nothing in the 30 odd years since Led Zeps untimely demise, the album is very tight. The timing is particular noticeable and this allows Homme a fantastic platform for some guitar work that we have not heard from his since, funnily enough, he last worked with Grohl on the Songs for the Deaf album (Queens of the Stone Age) This is one formula that works here. Homme shows his voice has continued to improve as it has on each Queens album, the man has a great vocal range, certainly along way removed from Feelgood hit of the summer ('Nicotine, Valium, Vicodin, Marijuana, Ecstasy and Alcohol C-c-c-c-c-cocaine) if you had forgotten. To most mainstream commercial radio listners he would be the least known of the group, but really he is the guitars and vocals and if anything many of the tracks are Queens of the Stone Age sounding - but - there is so much more. as you would expect from Grohl and JPJ, they are not going to take a back seat.

That is one of the highlights for me. The album actually works. Its better than anyone expected. The musical talent on show throughout is as phenomenal as you'd expect - Grohl plays drums like a man possessed - the cymbal work, drum rolls and timing changes throughout the album are brilliant. JPJ is the master producer. He made Led Zep sound that good as well as every other band he ever produced.

It's thrilling just to hear these three men play together, you can almost hear the guys having fun, Homme and Grohl getting to live out a boyhood fantasy. However if there can be a criticism, that is probably born out of this very point. There are drums solos, guitar solos, bass riffs galore. I mean galore. Its packed. It is fantastic - but at times it is a bit meaty.

In the end it is what i paid for though, i wanted a big album with screeching soaring guitar solos, big riffs, pounding drums with roll after roll all topped with a voice that moves between a shot and a croons.

In this case the sum of the parts were never going to be greater than the original bands from whence they came (except the Foo Fighters of course with apologies to their second album the colour and the shape), however them crooked vultures have put themselves right up there with a phenomenal debut.

And for christs sake lets call it a Side Project.